Mathematical Considerations (GNU Octave (version 7.3.0))

22.1.4.3 Mathematical Considerations

The attempt has been made to make sparse matrices behave in exactly the same manner as there full counterparts. However, there are certain differences and especially differences with other products sparse implementations.

First, the "./" and ".^" operators must be used with care. Consider what the examples

  s = speye (4);
  a1 = s .^ 2;
  a2 = s .^ s;
  a3 = s .^ -2;
  a4 = s ./ 2;
  a5 = 2 ./ s;
  a6 = s ./ s;

will give. The first example of s raised to the power of 2 causes no problems. However s raised element-wise to itself involves a large number of terms 0 .^ 0 which is 1. There s .^ s is a full matrix.

Likewise s .^ -2 involves terms like 0 .^ -2 which is infinity, and so s .^ -2 is equally a full matrix.

For the "./" operator s ./ 2 has no problems, but 2 ./ s involves a large number of infinity terms as well and is equally a full matrix. The case of s ./ s involves terms like 0 ./ 0 which is a NaN and so this is equally a full matrix with the zero elements of s filled with NaN values.

The above behavior is consistent with full matrices, but is not consistent with sparse implementations in other products.

A particular problem of sparse matrices comes about due to the fact that as the zeros are not stored, the sign-bit of these zeros is equally not stored. In certain cases the sign-bit of zero is important. For example:

 a = 0 ./ [-1, 1; 1, -1];
 b = 1 ./ a
 ⇒ -Inf            Inf
     Inf           -Inf
 c = 1 ./ sparse (a)
 ⇒  Inf            Inf
     Inf            Inf

To correct this behavior would mean that zero elements with a negative sign-bit would need to be stored in the matrix to ensure that their sign-bit was respected. This is not done at this time, for reasons of efficiency, and so the user is warned that calculations where the sign-bit of zero is important must not be done using sparse matrices.

In general any function or operator used on a sparse matrix will result in a sparse matrix with the same or a larger number of nonzero elements than the original matrix. This is particularly true for the important case of sparse matrix factorizations. The usual way to address this is to reorder the matrix, such that its factorization is sparser than the factorization of the original matrix. That is the factorization of L * U = P * S * Q has sparser terms L and U than the equivalent factorization L * U = S.

Several functions are available to reorder depending on the type of the matrix to be factorized. If the matrix is symmetric positive-definite, then symamd or csymamd should be used. Otherwise amd, colamd or ccolamd should be used. For completeness the reordering functions colperm and randperm are also available.

See Figure 22.3, for an example of the structure of a simple positive definite matrix.

Figure 22.3: Structure of simple sparse matrix.

The standard Cholesky factorization of this matrix can be obtained by the same command that would be used for a full matrix. This can be visualized with the command r = chol (A); spy (r);. See Figure 22.4. The original matrix had 598 nonzero terms, while this Cholesky factorization has 10200, with only half of the symmetric matrix being stored. This is a significant level of fill in, and although not an issue for such a small test case, can represents a large overhead in working with other sparse matrices.

The appropriate sparsity preserving permutation of the original matrix is given by symamd and the factorization using this reordering can be visualized using the command q = symamd (A); r = chol (A(q,q)); spy (r). This gives 399 nonzero terms which is a significant improvement.

The Cholesky factorization itself can be used to determine the appropriate sparsity preserving reordering of the matrix during the factorization, In that case this might be obtained with three return arguments as [r, p, q] = chol (A); spy (r).

Figure 22.4: Structure of the unpermuted Cholesky factorization of the above matrix.

Figure 22.5: Structure of the permuted Cholesky factorization of the above matrix.

In the case of an asymmetric matrix, the appropriate sparsity preserving permutation is colamd and the factorization using this reordering can be visualized using the command q = colamd (A); [l, u, p] = lu (A(:,q)); spy (l+u).

Finally, Octave implicitly reorders the matrix when using the div (/) and ldiv (\) operators, and so no the user does not need to explicitly reorder the matrix to maximize performance.

: p = amd (S) ¶

: p = amd (S, opts) ¶

Return the approximate minimum degree permutation of a matrix.

This is a permutation such that the Cholesky factorization of S (p, p) tends to be sparser than the Cholesky factorization of S itself. amd is typically faster than symamd but serves a similar purpose.

The optional parameter opts is a structure that controls the behavior of amd. The fields of the structure are

opts.dense: Determines what amd considers to be a dense row or column of the input matrix. Rows or columns with more than max (16, (dense * sqrt (n))) entries, where n is the order of the matrix S, are ignored by amd during the calculation of the permutation. The value of dense must be a positive scalar and the default value is 10.0
opts.aggressive: If this value is a nonzero scalar, then amd performs aggressive absorption. The default is not to perform aggressive absorption.

The author of the code itself is Timothy A. Davis (see http://faculty.cse.tamu.edu/davis/suitesparse.html).

See also: symamd, colamd.

: p = ccolamd (S) ¶

: p = ccolamd (S, knobs) ¶

: p = ccolamd (S, knobs, cmember) ¶

: [p, stats] = ccolamd (…) ¶

Constrained column approximate minimum degree permutation.

p = ccolamd (S) returns the column approximate minimum degree permutation vector for the sparse matrix S. For a non-symmetric matrix S, S(:, p) tends to have sparser LU factors than S. chol (S(:, p)' * S(:, p)) also tends to be sparser than chol (S' * S). p = ccolamd (S, 1) optimizes the ordering for lu (S(:, p)). The ordering is followed by a column elimination tree post-ordering.

knobs is an optional 1-element to 5-element input vector, with a default value of [0 10 10 1 0] if not present or empty. Entries not present are set to their defaults.

knobs(1): if nonzero, the ordering is optimized for lu (S(:, p)). It will be a poor ordering for chol (S(:, p)' * S(:, p)). This is the most important knob for ccolamd.
knobs(2): if S is m-by-n, rows with more than max (16, knobs(2) * sqrt (n)) entries are ignored.
knobs(3): columns with more than max (16, knobs(3) * sqrt (min (m, n))) entries are ignored and ordered last in the output permutation (subject to the cmember constraints).
knobs(4): if nonzero, aggressive absorption is performed.
knobs(5): if nonzero, statistics and knobs are printed.

cmember is an optional vector of length n. It defines the constraints on the column ordering. If cmember(j) = c, then column j is in constraint set c (c must be in the range 1 to n). In the output permutation p, all columns in set 1 appear first, followed by all columns in set 2, and so on. cmember = ones (1,n) if not present or empty. ccolamd (S, [], 1 : n) returns 1 : n

p = ccolamd (S) is about the same as p = colamd (S). knobs and its default values differ. colamd always does aggressive absorption, and it finds an ordering suitable for both lu (S(:, p)) and chol (S(:, p)' * S(:, p)); it cannot optimize its ordering for lu (S(:, p)) to the extent that ccolamd (S, 1) can.

stats is an optional 20-element output vector that provides data about the ordering and the validity of the input matrix S. Ordering statistics are in stats(1 : 3). stats(1) and stats(2) are the number of dense or empty rows and columns ignored by CCOLAMD and stats(3) is the number of garbage collections performed on the internal data structure used by CCOLAMD (roughly of size 2.2 * nnz (S) + 4 * m + 7 * n integers).

stats(4 : 7) provide information if CCOLAMD was able to continue. The matrix is OK if stats(4) is zero, or 1 if invalid. stats(5) is the rightmost column index that is unsorted or contains duplicate entries, or zero if no such column exists. stats(6) is the last seen duplicate or out-of-order row index in the column index given by stats(5), or zero if no such row index exists. stats(7) is the number of duplicate or out-of-order row indices. stats(8 : 20) is always zero in the current version of CCOLAMD (reserved for future use).

The authors of the code itself are S. Larimore, T. Davis and S. Rajamanickam in collaboration with J. Bilbert and E. Ng. Supported by the National Science Foundation (DMS-9504974, DMS-9803599, CCR-0203270), and a grant from Sandia National Lab. See http://faculty.cse.tamu.edu/davis/suitesparse.html for ccolamd, csymamd, amd, colamd, symamd, and other related orderings.

See also: colamd, csymamd.

: p = colamd (S) ¶

: p = colamd (S, knobs) ¶

: [p, stats] = colamd (S) ¶

: [p, stats] = colamd (S, knobs) ¶

Compute the column approximate minimum degree permutation.

p = colamd (S) returns the column approximate minimum degree permutation vector for the sparse matrix S. For a non-symmetric matrix S, S(:,p) tends to have sparser LU factors than S. The Cholesky factorization of S(:,p)' * S(:,p) also tends to be sparser than that of S' * S.

knobs is an optional one- to three-element input vector. If S is m-by-n, then rows with more than max(16,knobs(1)*sqrt(n)) entries are ignored. Columns with more than max (16,knobs(2)*sqrt(min(m,n))) entries are removed prior to ordering, and ordered last in the output permutation p. Only completely dense rows or columns are removed if knobs(1) and knobs(2) are < 0, respectively. If knobs(3) is nonzero, stats and knobs are printed. The default is knobs = [10 10 0]. Note that knobs differs from earlier versions of colamd.

stats is an optional 20-element output vector that provides data about the ordering and the validity of the input matrix S. Ordering statistics are in stats(1:3). stats(1) and stats(2) are the number of dense or empty rows and columns ignored by COLAMD and stats(3) is the number of garbage collections performed on the internal data structure used by COLAMD (roughly of size 2.2 * nnz(S) + 4 * m + 7 * n integers).

Octave built-in functions are intended to generate valid sparse matrices, with no duplicate entries, with ascending row indices of the nonzeros in each column, with a non-negative number of entries in each column (!) and so on. If a matrix is invalid, then COLAMD may or may not be able to continue. If there are duplicate entries (a row index appears two or more times in the same column) or if the row indices in a column are out of order, then COLAMD can correct these errors by ignoring the duplicate entries and sorting each column of its internal copy of the matrix S (the input matrix S is not repaired, however). If a matrix is invalid in other ways then COLAMD cannot continue, an error message is printed, and no output arguments (p or stats) are returned. COLAMD is thus a simple way to check a sparse matrix to see if it’s valid.

stats(4:7) provide information if COLAMD was able to continue. The matrix is OK if stats(4) is zero, or 1 if invalid. stats(5) is the rightmost column index that is unsorted or contains duplicate entries, or zero if no such column exists. stats(6) is the last seen duplicate or out-of-order row index in the column index given by stats(5), or zero if no such row index exists. stats(7) is the number of duplicate or out-of-order row indices. stats(8:20) is always zero in the current version of COLAMD (reserved for future use).

The ordering is followed by a column elimination tree post-ordering.

The authors of the code itself are Stefan I. Larimore and Timothy A. Davis. The algorithm was developed in collaboration with John Gilbert, Xerox PARC, and Esmond Ng, Oak Ridge National Laboratory. (see http://faculty.cse.tamu.edu/davis/suitesparse.html)

See also: colperm, symamd, ccolamd.

: p = colperm (s) ¶

Return the column permutations such that the columns of s(:, p) are ordered in terms of increasing number of nonzero elements.

If s is symmetric, then p is chosen such that s(p, p) orders the rows and columns with increasing number of nonzero elements.

: p = csymamd (S) ¶

: p = csymamd (S, knobs) ¶

: p = csymamd (S, knobs, cmember) ¶

: [p, stats] = csymamd (…) ¶

For a symmetric positive definite matrix S, return the permutation vector p such that S(p,p) tends to have a sparser Cholesky factor than S.

Sometimes csymamd works well for symmetric indefinite matrices too. The matrix S is assumed to be symmetric; only the strictly lower triangular part is referenced. S must be square. The ordering is followed by an elimination tree post-ordering.

knobs is an optional 1-element to 3-element input vector, with a default value of [10 1 0]. Entries not present are set to their defaults.

knobs(1): If S is n-by-n, then rows and columns with more than max(16,knobs(1)*sqrt(n)) entries are ignored, and ordered last in the output permutation (subject to the cmember constraints).
knobs(2): If nonzero, aggressive absorption is performed.
knobs(3): If nonzero, statistics and knobs are printed.

cmember is an optional vector of length n. It defines the constraints on the ordering. If cmember(j) = S, then row/column j is in constraint set c (c must be in the range 1 to n). In the output permutation p, rows/columns in set 1 appear first, followed by all rows/columns in set 2, and so on. cmember = ones (1,n) if not present or empty. csymamd (S,[],1:n) returns 1:n.

p = csymamd (S) is about the same as p = symamd (S). knobs and its default values differ.

stats(4:7) provide information if CCOLAMD was able to continue. The matrix is OK if stats(4) is zero, or 1 if invalid. stats(5) is the rightmost column index that is unsorted or contains duplicate entries, or zero if no such column exists. stats(6) is the last seen duplicate or out-of-order row index in the column index given by stats(5), or zero if no such row index exists. stats(7) is the number of duplicate or out-of-order row indices. stats(8:20) is always zero in the current version of CCOLAMD (reserved for future use).

The authors of the code itself are S. Larimore, T. Davis and S. Rajamanickam in collaboration with J. Bilbert and E. Ng. Supported by the National Science Foundation (DMS-9504974, DMS-9803599, CCR-0203270), and a grant from Sandia National Lab. See http://faculty.cse.tamu.edu/davis/suitesparse.html for ccolamd, colamd, csymamd, amd, colamd, symamd, and other related orderings.

See also: symamd, ccolamd.

: p = dmperm (A) ¶

: [p, q, r, s, cc, rr] = dmperm (A) ¶

Perform a Dulmage-Mendelsohn permutation of the sparse matrix A.

With a single output argument dmperm, return a maximum matching p such that p(j) = i if column j is matched to row i, or 0 if column j is unmatched. If A is square and full structural rank, p is a row permutation and A(p,:) has a zero-free diagonal. The structural rank of A is sprank(A) = sum(p>0).

Called with two or more output arguments, return the Dulmage-Mendelsohn decomposition of A. p and q are permutation vectors. cc and rr are vectors of length 5. c = A(p,q) is split into a 4-by-4 set of coarse blocks:

   A11 A12 A13 A14
    0  0   A23 A24
    0  0    0  A34
    0  0    0  A44

where A12, A23, and A34 are square with zero-free diagonals. The columns of A11 are the unmatched columns, and the rows of A44 are the unmatched rows. Any of these blocks can be empty. In the "coarse" decomposition, the (i,j)-th block is C(rr(i):rr(i+1)-1,cc(j):cc(j+1)-1). In terms of a linear system, [A11 A12] is the underdetermined part of the system (it is always rectangular and with more columns and rows, or 0-by-0), A23 is the well-determined part of the system (it is always square), and [A34 ; A44] is the over-determined part of the system (it is always rectangular with more rows than columns, or 0-by-0).

The structural rank of A is sprank (A) = rr(4)-1, which is an upper bound on the numerical rank of A. sprank(A) = rank(full(sprand(A))) with probability 1 in exact arithmetic.

The A23 submatrix is further subdivided into block upper triangular form via the "fine" decomposition (the strongly-connected components of A23). If A is square and structurally non-singular, A23 is the entire matrix.

C(r(i):r(i+1)-1,s(j):s(j+1)-1) is the (i,j)-th block of the fine decomposition. The (1,1) block is the rectangular block [A11 A12], unless this block is 0-by-0. The (b,b) block is the rectangular block [A34 ; A44], unless this block is 0-by-0, where b = length(r)-1. All other blocks of the form C(r(i):r(i+1)-1,s(i):s(i+1)-1) are diagonal blocks of A23, and are square with a zero-free diagonal.

The method used is described in: A. Pothen & C.-J. Fan. Computing the Block Triangular Form of a Sparse Matrix. ACM Trans. Math. Software, 16(4):303–324, 1990.

See also: colamd, ccolamd.

: p = symamd (S) ¶

: p = symamd (S, knobs) ¶

: [p, stats] = symamd (S) ¶

: [p, stats] = symamd (S, knobs) ¶

For a symmetric positive definite matrix S, returns the permutation vector p such that S(p, p) tends to have a sparser Cholesky factor than S.

Sometimes symamd works well for symmetric indefinite matrices too. The matrix S is assumed to be symmetric; only the strictly lower triangular part is referenced. S must be square.

knobs is an optional one- to two-element input vector. If S is n-by-n, then rows and columns with more than max (16,knobs(1)*sqrt(n)) entries are removed prior to ordering, and ordered last in the output permutation p. No rows/columns are removed if knobs(1) < 0. If knobs(2) is nonzero, stats and knobs are printed. The default is knobs = [10 0]. Note that knobs differs from earlier versions of symamd.

stats is an optional 20-element output vector that provides data about the ordering and the validity of the input matrix S. Ordering statistics are in stats(1:3). stats(1) = stats(2) is the number of dense or empty rows and columns ignored by SYMAMD and stats(3) is the number of garbage collections performed on the internal data structure used by SYMAMD (roughly of size 8.4 * nnz (tril (S, -1)) + 9 * n integers).

Octave built-in functions are intended to generate valid sparse matrices, with no duplicate entries, with ascending row indices of the nonzeros in each column, with a non-negative number of entries in each column (!) and so on. If a matrix is invalid, then SYMAMD may or may not be able to continue. If there are duplicate entries (a row index appears two or more times in the same column) or if the row indices in a column are out of order, then SYMAMD can correct these errors by ignoring the duplicate entries and sorting each column of its internal copy of the matrix S (the input matrix S is not repaired, however). If a matrix is invalid in other ways then SYMAMD cannot continue, an error message is printed, and no output arguments (p or stats) are returned. SYMAMD is thus a simple way to check a sparse matrix to see if it’s valid.

stats(4:7) provide information if SYMAMD was able to continue. The matrix is OK if stats (4) is zero, or 1 if invalid. stats(5) is the rightmost column index that is unsorted or contains duplicate entries, or zero if no such column exists. stats(6) is the last seen duplicate or out-of-order row index in the column index given by stats(5), or zero if no such row index exists. stats(7) is the number of duplicate or out-of-order row indices. stats(8:20) is always zero in the current version of SYMAMD (reserved for future use).

The ordering is followed by a column elimination tree post-ordering.

See also: colperm, colamd.

: p = symrcm (S) ¶

Return the symmetric reverse Cuthill-McKee permutation of S.

p is a permutation vector such that S(p, p) tends to have its diagonal elements closer to the diagonal than S. This is a good preordering for LU or Cholesky factorization of matrices that come from “long, skinny” problems. It works for both symmetric and asymmetric S.

The algorithm represents a heuristic approach to the NP-complete bandwidth minimization problem. The implementation is based in the descriptions found in

E. Cuthill, J. McKee. Reducing the Bandwidth of Sparse Symmetric Matrices. Proceedings of the 24th ACM National Conference, 157–172 1969, Brandon Press, New Jersey.

A. George, J.W.H. Liu. Computer Solution of Large Sparse Positive Definite Systems, Prentice Hall Series in Computational Mathematics, ISBN 0-13-165274-5, 1981.

See also: colperm, colamd, symamd.